Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Chicken & Spinach
Calzone With Sauce (Large)
Cheese Sticks With Sauce Small
Cheese Stick With Sauce Large
About
Benny's Pizza Milan
Welcome to Benny's Pizza Milan, a delightful gem nestled at 687 Hillcrest Rd, Milan, IL. This establishment has rapidly gained a reputation for its mouthwatering pizza and charming atmosphere, making it a go-to spot for pizza lovers in the area.
One of the standout features of Benny's is the sheer quality of their food. Patrons rave about the freshness of the pizzas, particularly the popular "bankers pizza" that left Jeff Mower thoroughly impressed. With your meal prepared to perfection and ready for pick-up, it's clear that convenience and quality are top priorities at this beloved pizzeria.
Another highlight is their versatility; as noted by Sher TM, Benny's offers a fantastic venue to enjoy not just pizza, but also a cool drink—be it a beer or a glass of wine—while savoring their delicious 8" pizzas and calzones. This pairing makes for a perfect relaxed evening out.
Your first visit can be just as rewarding, as Lindsey Horton discovered. The friendly staff is eager to ensure your experience is as smooth and enjoyable as possible. Although the prices might lean a bit higher, the outstanding flavor and quality justify the expense. If you’re in the mood for a comforting cheese stick, make sure to try those too; they came highly recommended by Lindsey’s family, including her discerning toddler.
Inclusivity is key at Benny's. Alaina Hanson, a customer with dietary restrictions, was met with exceptional kindness from Madison, who patiently helped her navigate the menu. The ability to create your own pizza means that everyone can find something to enjoy, no matter their dietary needs. The bacon cheeseburger pizza, served with pickles on the side, has become a personal favorite of patrons seeking customization.
Whether you are after a quick takeout, a cozy dine-in experience, or a way to accommodate unique dietary needs without sacrificing flavor, Benny's Pizza Milan is a must-visit. With its warm atmosphere and dedication to quality, every bite promises to leave you craving more.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ We ordered a bankers pizza for carry out. The pizza was very good and was ready when we arrived. We will be ordering again soon. ”
“ Great little place to have a beer/glass of wine & pizza or calzone. We had 2 8" pizzas. AWESOME! Will try a calzone next time! ”
“ Always good pizza, especially if you go in and eat it fresh out of the oven! ”
“ This was my first time trying Benny's. I ordered a large pepperoni pizza and a small cheese stick to go. The employees were friendly and they got done making my food right when their estimated time was. The total was around 35 after taxes, so it's a little bit pricey, but I was very happy with the taste and quality of the food. This was one of the best pizzas I've had in the QCA. I will definitely be back to try some specialty pizzas. Also, I HIGHLY recommend the cheese sticks. Myself, my husband, and our very picky young toddler devoured that! ”
“ I have a condition called diverticulitis it's easier to state that it's an allergy, upon my visit tonight I ran into a young lady named Madison she went through everything with me bent over backwards I'm very limited on things I can eat and help give me a new list of items I can eat and create my own pizzas I was so appreciative she was absolutely wonderful! You can put together everything make your own whatever I do the bacon cheeseburger pizza because the pickles are on the side and I can tolerate it I just want to send a shout out to her and Benny's Pizza in general along with the crew tonight they went above and beyond! ”
“ Love this place for old time memories. Great pizza ”
“ The pizza and calzones are always great - cooked to perfection! ”
“ One of the best places I’ve been for pizza. I don’t live in the area but when I’m in the quad cities I’ll pick up a pizza from here (and some cheese sticks) It’s usually the banker’s special. The sausage they use tastes different than other pizza places but it’s delicious! The pizza reheats perfectly in the oven in case you don’t finish it. Definitely stop by for some pizza! ”